In my GA days I flew mainly C172s (M,N P models) and lastly the S variant with a 180hp IO360 engine, and also Piper Cherokee Archer 2 & 3 PA28-181 180 HP carburettor variants.
Both had good and bad points.
C172 good points - easy to get in & out of, no requirement to change fuel tanks, 40 deg of flap on the early models.
C172 bad points - heavy controls, Upright kitchen chair style pilot seating, slow electric flaps, quite noisy. PITA to refuel
PA28-181 good points - comfortable seating, nicer lighter controls (quadrant) easy x wind landing/ground effect, easy to refuel & check fuel, good comfortable tourer, more grunt, quieter.
PA28-181 bad points - Single door on RH side for access, having to remember to change fuel tanks.
Overall I preferred the Archer despite changing tanks every 1/2 hour & getting in and out of it. That most likely influenced my choice of a low wing RA aircraft to build. My Sierra handles X winds very well compared to the Jabirus, Gazelles and Foxbats I've flown.