The CFI and BFR issue: If a pilot has been getting noticed for irresponsible behaviour, or perhaps lapses of skill, then it behoves the CFI to take that into account as well as the actual performance during the BFR. However, I feel that our culture does not go far enough to support the brave CFI who sincerely wants to take action to get a pilot to improve his culture or skill level. After all it will involve a loss of face for the pilot in question, and impose the expense of further training ( and risks the counter argument that "he's not all that bad" and the CFI stands to make money out of it, etc ....) It undoubtably would cause some ill feeling. So we need to offer better support to our CFI's if we are to use them to be the air policemen. As has been pointed out there is not much in our 'self regulation' to allow control. We really don't want to end up with heavy handed government regulation and if we are to be allowed to self regulate then it is up to US the members to regulate those who are creating our cowboy reputation, and those who should do more training.